The appeal in the case of The Governors of Sutton’s Hospital in Charterhouse (UKSC/2025/0143) was heard in the Supreme Court earlier this month.
The appeal concerned the ”prescribed information” which a landlord must give to a tenant when a deposit is taken in respect of an assured shorthold tenancy and whether a landlord, which protected the tenancy deposit and told its tenant what it needed to know, can then be penalised because its paperwork did not follow the prescribed form to the letter.
Section 213(6)(a) of the Housing Act 2004 permits the information to be given “in the prescribed form or a form substantially to the same effect”.
The Governors of Sutton’s Hospital in Charterhouse is the landlord and a registered charity. It let a flat at Preachers Court, Charterhouse to Mr Lowe in January 2010. Mr Lowe paid a deposit of £3,300 under a written tenancy agreement which he signed and initialled.
The tenancy was not an assured shorthold tenancy at the start but became one in October 2010 when the rent limited for assured tenancies was raised. The landlord, out of an abundance of caution, protected the deposit in advance of the change and sent Mr Lowe the certificate of prescribed information, along with a covering letter asking Mr Lowe to sign and return it.
The certificate referenced deductions “according to clause 6 of the tenancy agreement attached”. However, there was no clause 6 in the tenancy agreement and the correct clause was 5.3. Further, the agent had signed the covering letter rather than the certificate itself.
A notice seeking possession was served in 2021. Mr Lowe as tenant is claiming £120,888. As well as the initial tenancy to Mr Lowe in 2010, there had been a number of intermittent renewals. Mr Lowe is claiming 3 x the deposit for each of those renewal tenancies, hence the £120,888 total claimed. This is one of the largest known tenancy deposit claims.
At the first hearing in the County Court, the judge found that the deposit had been protected, Mr Lowe knew it had been, and that the landlord’s agent had complied with the legislation.
The first appeal was dismissed, and the Court of Appeal also dismissed the second appeal.. On both occasions, the courts held that a reasonable recipient of the certificate would have appreciated the slip and found the deposit clause in his own tenancy agreement. In addition both courts found that the certificate and the covering letter read together had substantially the same effect as a signed certificate.
The Supreme Court granted permission to appeal in December 2025 and, at the hearing on 3 November, considered two questions:
- Whether “information required” in the Housing (Tenancy Deposits)(Prescribed Information) Order 2007 (article 2(1)(g)(vi) is satisfied when the prescribed information refers to the wrong clause in the tenancy agreement but this is an obvious error and the tenant had already signed the tenancy agreement that contained the deposit clause; and
- Whether the “confirmation requirement” in article 2(1)(g)(vii) of the 2007 order is satisfied where the landlord’s agent signs the covering letter rather than the certificate, even though the two documents were sent together and the tenant was asked to sign and return the certificate.
The decision by the Supreme Court will have far reaching consequences, particularly since the Renters Rights Act 2025 extended the tenancy deposit scheme from assured shorthold tenancies to all private sector assured tenancies on 1 May 2026.
If the Supreme Court finds in Mr Lowe’s favour, then even if a landlord has protected the deposit and given the tenant the prescribed information, if it has made an error on the prescribed information, then it could face a penalty of up to three times the deposit for every tenancy granted to that tenant and, unless it first returns the deposit, it may not be able to recover possession of its own property.
Given the potentially far reaching consequences of this case, we will provide an update on the decision by the Supreme Court when judgment is handed down.
Lowe v The Governors of Sutton’s Hospital in Charterhouse (UKSC/2025/0143)